| PARTY NAME | PARTY ROLE | CASE NO | FILE DATE | TYPE/ CODE | CAUSE OF ACTION/ CASE CATEGORY/ CHARGE CODE | CAPTION | FILE LOCATION | STATUS |
| ACA RECEIVABLES CO | P | 623854 | 2/19/2008 | CV | MCOMP | ACA RECEIVABLES VS. BUZZINI MANAGEMENT | MUNI | CLOSED |
| ACADEMY VIDEO | D | 626126 | 4/23/2008 | CV | MCOMP | LN ACQUISITIONS INC VS CHHEAV, S | MUNI | OPEN |
| ACASIO GLENDA PASCUAL | D | 1275632 | 3/25/2008 | TRF | I | THE PEOPLE VS ACASIO, GLENDA PASCUAL | TUR | CLOSED |
| ACCELERATED CONCRETE CUTTING | D | 626891 | 5/12/2008 | CV | MCOMP | VALLEY PACIFIC VS. ACCELERATED CONCRETE | MUNI | OPEN |
| ACCESS CAPITAL SERVICES INC | P | 624510 | 2/24/2008 | CV | MCOMP | ACCESS CAPITAL VS, MORALES, M | MUNI | OPEN |
| ACCESS CAPITAL SERVICES INC | P | 625835 | 4/2/2008 | CV | MCOMP | ACCESS CAPITAL VS. SEGOBIA, G | MUNI | OPEN |
| ACCESS CAPITAL SERVICES INC | P | 626620 | 5/1/2008 | CV | MCOMP | ACCESS CAPITAL SERVICES VS MORRISON, K | MUNI | OPEN |
| ACCESS CAPITAL SERVICES INC | P | 626833 | 5/12/2008 | CV | MCOMP | ACCESS CAPITAL VS. TAYLOR, J | MUNI | OPEN |
| ACCESS CAPITAL SERVICES INC | P | 626835 | 4/28/2008 | CV | MCOMP | ACCESS CAPITAL SERVICES VS DICKSON, D | MUNI | OPEN |
| ACCESS CAPITAL SERVICES, INC | P | 625649 | 4/1/2008 | CV | MCOMP | ACCESS CAPITAL VS SANDERS, S | MUNI | OPEN |
| ACCESS CAPTIAL SERVICES, INC | P | 627307 | 6/2/2008 | CV | MCOMP | ACCESS CAPITAL SERVICES | MUNI | OPEN |
| ACCLAIM CREDIT TECHNOLOGIES | P | 623125 | 1/22/2008 | CV | MCOMP | ACCLAIM CREDIT VS RUIZ, F | MUNI | OPEN |
| ACCLAIM CREDIT TECHNOLOGIES | P | 623449 | 1/31/2008 | CV | MCOMP | ACCLAIM CREDIT VS OBANDO, J | MUNI | HOLD |
| ACCLAIM CREDIT TECHNOLOGIES | P | 627392 | 6/3/2008 | CV | MCOMP | ACCLAIM CREDIT TECH VX SALAZAR, C | MUNI | OPEN |
| ACCOUNT MANAGEMENT SERVICES | P | 623197 | 1/24/2008 | CV | MCOMP | ACCOUNT MANAGEMENT VS. WILDT, M | MUNI | OPEN |
| ACCREDITED HOME LENDERS, INC | P | 623743 | 2/15/2008 | CV | UD | ACCREDITED HOME LENDERS V CONTRERAS, L A | MUNI | CLOSED |
| ACCURATE DELIVERY SYSTEMS INC | D | 624201 | 2/15/2008 | CV | MCOMP | PROGRESSIVE WEST VS. DAVIS, P | MUNI | OPEN |
| ACCURSO ANTHONY | D | 626239 | 4/25/2008 | CV | MCOMP | BENEFICIAL CALIFORNIA VS, ACCURSO, A | MUNI | OPEN |
| ACE GRINDING | D | 626096 | 4/10/2008 | CV | MCOMP | CITICAPITAL COMMERCIAL VS. VANDERHELM, J | SUPER | OPEN |
| ACE GRINDING LLC | D | 628752 | 7/10/2008 | CV | MCOMP | HOLLISTER, P VS VANDERHELM, J | SUPER | OPEN |
| ACE LATHING AND PLASTERING | D | 624949 | 3/18/2008 | CV | MCOMP | DOWNEY, R VS FILIPPINI, R | MUNI | CLOSED |
| ACE LATHING, INC. | P | 624878 | 3/17/2008 | CV | MCOMP | ACE LATHING VS PACIFIC PRIDE | SUPER | OPEN |
| ACE LATHING, INC. | P | 624879 | 3/17/2008 | CV | MCOMP | ACE LATHING VS PACIFIC PRIDE | SUPER | OPEN |
| ACE LAWN CARE | D | 1278448 | 5/19/2008 | TRF | I | THE PEOPLE VS ACE LAWN CARE | TUR | OPEN |
| ACE LAWN CARE | D | 1278449 | 5/19/2008 | TRF | I | THE PEOPLE VS ACE LAWN CARE | TUR | OPEN |
| ACE MAKER HATCHERY | D | 627532 | 6/3/2008 | CV | MCOMP | CAPITAL ONE BANK VS. DEIPARINE, R | MUNI | OPEN |
| ACENA MELISSA | D | 408791 | 2/11/2008 | FC | CS | CO VS. ACENA, M | SUPER | OPEN |
| ACEVEDO ANA | D | 394794 | 2/13/2008 | SC | SCI | SANDOVAL VS RNAGEL | TRF | CLOSED |
| ACEVEDO ANA | PET | 429318 | 6/10/2008 | FAM | DV | ACEVEDO, A VS. FIGUEROA, M | SUPER | OPEN |
| ACEVEDO ANA BERTHA | D | 1509736 | 6/12/2008 | TRF | I | THE PEOPLE VS ACEVEDO, ANA BERTHA | TRF | OPEN |
| ACEVEDO ANDRES BAUTISTA | D | 1274893 | 3/24/2008 | TRF | I | THE PEOPLE VS ACEVEDO, ANDRES BAUTISTA | TUR | OPEN |
| ACEVEDO DANIEL | RSP | 429438 | 6/18/2008 | FAM | DV | FIGUEROA, M VS. ACEVEDO, D | SUPER | OPEN |
| ACEVEDO DANIEL | D | 1387570 | 1/30/2008 | TRF | I | THE PEOPLE VS ACEVEDO, DANIEL | TRF | CLOSED |
| ACEVEDO DANIEL ARREGUIN | D | 1243596 | 4/7/2008 | CR | MISDEM | PEO VS ACEVEDO, DANIEL ARREGUIN | MUNI | PS |
| ACEVEDO DAVID | D | 1279860 | 6/12/2008 | TRF | I | THE PEOPLE VS ACEVEDO, DAVID | TUR | OPEN |
| ACEVEDO DELFINO | P | 624643 | 3/10/2008 | CV | UD | ACEVEDO, D VS GONZALEZ, M | MUNI | OPEN |
| ACEVEDO DENNIS MARVIN | D | 1238843 | 1/16/2008 | CR | MISDEM | PEO VS ACEVEDO, DENNIS MARVIN | MUNI | OPEN |
| ACEVEDO DENNIS MARVIN | D | 1503103 | 5/12/2008 | TRF | I | THE PEOPLE VS ACEVEDO, DENNIS MARVIN | TRF | OPEN |
| ACEVEDO DIEGO | D | 1278359 | 5/15/2008 | TRF | I | THE PEOPLE VS ACEVEDO, DIEGO | TUR | OPEN |
| ACEVEDO ESTELA | D | 1511526 | 6/19/2008 | TRF | I | THE PEOPLE VS ACEVEDO, ESTELA | TRF | OPEN |
| ACEVEDO FERNANDO CARDENAS | D | 1277909 | 5/6/2008 | TRF | I | THE PEOPLE VS ACEVEDO, FERNANDO CARDENAS | TUR | OPEN |
| ACEVEDO HERIBERTO RIVERA | RSP | 427587 | 2/4/2008 | FAM | NULL | GREGORIAN, T VS. ACVEDO, H | SUPER | OPEN |
| ACEVEDO JAVIER | D | 1385694 | 1/15/2008 | TRF | I | THE PEOPLE VS ACEVEDO, JAVIER | TRF | CLOSED |
| ACEVEDO JAVIER | D | 1387282 | 1/29/2008 | TRF | I | THE PEOPLE VS ACEVEDO, JAVIER | TRF | CLOSED |
| ACEVEDO JUDITH ANNE | D | 1399156 | 4/18/2008 | TRF | I | THE PEOPLE VS ACEVEDO, JUDITH ANNE | TRF | CLOSED |
| ACEVEDO MONICA NICOLE | D | 1397054 | 4/8/2008 | TRF | I | THE PEOPLE VS ACEVEDO, MONICA NICOLE | TRF | OPEN |
| ACEVEDO PANANDLE CORRAL | D | 1275192 | 4/3/2008 | TRF | I | THE PEOPLE VS ACEVEDO, PANANDLE CORRAL | TUR | CLOSED |
| ACEVEDO ROSA | D | 623220 | 1/31/2008 | CV | MCOMP | AFS ASSIGNEE VS. ACEVEDO, R | MUNI | CLOSED |
| ACEVEDO ROSA | D | 623473 | 2/7/2008 | CV | MCOMP | LVNV FUNDING VS ACEVEDO, R | MUNI | CLOSED |
| ACEVEDO ROSA | D | 625513 | 4/7/2008 | CV | MCOMP | WORLDWIDE ASSET PURCHASING V. ACEVEDO, R | MUNI | CLOSED |
| ACEVEDO ROSALIO | D | 1242977 | 4/1/2008 | CR | FELONY | PEO VS ACEVEDO, ROSALIO | SUPER | PS |
| ACEVEDO ROSALIO | D | 1244903 | 6/19/2008 | CR | FELONY | PEO VS ACEVEDO, ROSALIO | SUPER | OPEN |
| ACEVEDO RUDY | D | 1507570 | 6/3/2008 | TRF | I | THE PEOPLE VS ACEVEDO JR, RUDY | TRF | OPEN |
| ACEVEDO RUDY | D | 1510119 | 6/13/2008 | TRF | I | THE PEOPLE VS ACEVEDO JR, RUDY | TRF | OPEN |
| ACEVEDO RUDY JAMES | D | 1397320 | 4/9/2008 | TRF | I | THE PEOPLE VS ACEVEDO, RUDY JAMES | TRF | OPEN |
| ACEVEDO SILVESTRE | D | 1242110 | 3/3/2008 | CR | MISDEM | PEO VS ACEVEDO, SILVESTRE | MUNI | OPEN |
| ACEVEDO URIEL SANCHEZ | D | 1503844 | 5/14/2008 | TRF | I | THE PEOPLE VS SANCHEZ, URIEL | TRF | OPEN |
| ACEVEDO YANCY NAPOLIS | D | 1277935 | 5/8/2008 | TRF | I | THE PEOPLE VS ACEVEDO, YANCY NAPOLIS | TUR | OPEN |
| ACEVES ALBERTO SILVA | D | 1006618 | 1/15/2008 | CR | MISDEM | PEO VS ACEVES, ALBERTO SILVA | MUNI | OPEN |
| ACEVES ALEJANDRA | D | 1511937 | 6/23/2008 | TRF | I | THE PEOPLE VS ACEVES, ALEJANDRA | TRF | OPEN |
| ACEVES JOEL | D | 1280163 | 6/19/2008 | TRF | I | THE PEOPLE VS ACEVES, JOEL | TUR | OPEN |
| ACEVES JUAN ANTONIO | D | 1511746 | 6/20/2008 | TRF | I | THE PEOPLE VS ACEVES, JUAN ANTONIO | TRF | OPEN |
| ACEVES LIZANDRO SANCHEZ | D | 1385493 | 1/11/2008 | TRF | I | THE PEOPLE VS ACEVES, LIZANDRO SANCHEZ | TRF | CLOSED |
| ACEVES MARTHA | D | 626488 | 5/2/2008 | CV | MCOMP | CAPITAL ONE BANK VS. ACEVES, M | MUNI | OPEN |
| ACEVES MARTHA | D | 627001 | 5/27/2008 | CV | MCOMP | ARROW FINANCIAL SERVICES VS ACEVES, M | MUNI | OPEN |
| ACHAIGUA JOHN PAUL | D | 1389882 | 2/14/2008 | TRF | I | THE PEOPLE VS ACHAIGUA, JOHN PAUL | TRF | CLOSED |
| ACHELPOHL MEGAN DEBORAH | D | 1389442 | 2/11/2008 | TRF | I | THE PEOPLE VS ACHELPOHL, MEGAN DEBORAH | TRF | CLOSED |
| ACIDERA MICHELLE | P | 394804 | 2/15/2008 | SC | SCI | ACIDERA VS FIERRO | TRF | CLOSED |
| ACIDERA MICHELLE | P | 395100 | 4/8/2008 | SC | SCI | ACIDERA VS COPPER RHINO LLC | TRF | CLOSED |
| ACIDERA MICHELLE | D | 1505025 | 5/21/2008 | TRF | I | THE PEOPLE VS ACIDERA, MICHELLE | TRF | OPEN |
| ACKENHEIL ALEXANDER EDWARD | D | 1391727 | 2/27/2008 | TRF | I | THE PEOPLE VS ACKENHEIL, ALEXANDER EDWAR | TRF | CLOSED |
| ACKENHEIL ALEXANDER EDWARD | D | 1509536 | 6/11/2008 | TRF | I | THE PEOPLE VS ACKENHEIL, ALEXANDER EDWAR | TRF | OPEN |
| ACKER FREDERICK GEORGE | D | 1277794 | 5/2/2008 | TRF | I | THE PEOPLE VS ACKER III, FREDERICK GEORG | TUR | OPEN |
| ACKER GERALD D STEVEN | D | 1388323 | 2/4/2008 | TRF | I | THE PEOPLE VS ACKER, GERALD D STEVEN | TRF | OPEN |
| ACKERMAN ERIN LYNN | D | 1046165 | 2/25/2008 | CR | MISDEM | PEO VS ACKERMAN, ERIN LYNN | MUNI | CLOSED |
| ACKERMAN ROBERT EDWARD | D | 1279804 | 6/13/2008 | TRF | I | THE PEOPLE VS ACKERMAN, ROBERT EDWARD | TUR | OPEN |
| ACKERSON CAROL ANN | D | 1395057 | 3/24/2008 | TRF | I | THE PEOPLE VS ACKERSON, CAROL ANN | TRF | OPEN |
| ACKERSON CHRISTINE JAMES | D | 1386474 | 1/22/2008 | TRF | I | THE PEOPLE VS ACKERSON, CHRISTINE JAMES | TRF | CLOSED |
| ACKERSON EMMA | D | 623487 | 2/7/2008 | CV | MCOMP | CHASE BANK VS ACKERSON, E | MUNI | CLOSED |
| ACKERSON RUTH C | D | 628464 | 6/26/2008 | CV | MCOMP | CAPITAL ONE BANK VS. ACKERSON, R | MUNI | OPEN |
| ACKLAND DENIS ALAN | D | 1277020 | 4/18/2008 | TRF | I | THE PEOPLE VS ACKLAND, DENIS ALAN | TUR | CLOSED |
| ACKLEY CATHERINE MARIE | D | 1502169 | 5/7/2008 | TRF | I | THE PEOPLE VS ACKLEY, CATHERINE MARIE | TRF | OPEN |
| ACME CONSTRUCTION COMPANY, INC | D | 624416 | 2/21/2008 | CV | MCOMP | ENGINEERED GLASS VS ACME CONSTRUCTION | SUPER | OPEN |
| ACME ELECTRIC COMPANY | P | 394599 | 1/9/2008 | SC | SCI | OLIVEIRA/LUCAS VS RAMADA INN ET AL | TRF | CLOSED |
| ACME ELECTRIC COMPANY | P | 394713 | 1/30/2008 | SC | SCI | OLIVEIRA/LUCAS VS DEL VALLE CAPITAL | TRF | CLOSED |
| ACME ELECTRIC COMPANY | P | 394739 | 2/4/2008 | SC | SCI | OLIVEIRA LUCAS ENTERPRISES VS ASAY | TRF | CLOSED |
| ACME ELECTRIC COMPANY | P | 395082 | 4/8/2008 | SC | SCO | OLIVEIRA/LUCAS ENT VS SPEARS | TRF | OPEN |
| ACME MOBILE | D | 624139 | 2/26/2008 | CV | UD | ANDREWS, K VS RAMIREZ, F | MUNI | OPEN |
| ACOBA MARIA VANESSA BAUTISTA | D | 1501726 | 5/8/2008 | TRF | I | THE PEOPLE VS ACOBA, MARIA VANESSA BAUTI | TRF | OPEN |
| ACOFF KEIDA | D | 625386 | 4/1/2008 | CV | UD | DEUTSCHE BANK VS ACOFF, K | MUNI | CLOSED |
| ACOLATSE DERRICK KWASHI | D | 1241727 | 2/25/2008 | CR | MISDEM | PEO VS ACOLATSE, DERRICK KWASHI | MUNI | PS |
| ACOSTA - SONS | D | 623056 | 1/25/2008 | CV | PIO | COUNTY OF STANISLAUS VS ACOSTA - SONS | MUNI | CLOSED |
| ACOSTA ADAM JOSEPH | D | 1398237 | 4/15/2008 | TRF | I | THE PEOPLE VS ACOSTA, ADAM JOSEPH | TRF | CLOSED |
| ACOSTA ADAM JOSEPH | D | 1511396 | 6/19/2008 | TRF | I | THE PEOPLE VS ACOSTA, ADAM JOSEPH | TRF | OPEN |
| ACOSTA ALBA Y | D | 1243420 | 4/2/2008 | CR | MISDEM | PEO VS ACOSTA, ALBA Y | MUNI | PS |
| ACOSTA ANTHONY L | PET | 429208 | 5/30/2008 | FAM | DISS | ACOSTA, A VS ACOSTA, M | SUPER | OPEN |
| ACOSTA ANTONIETA SILVIA | D | 1399775 | 4/23/2008 | TRF | I | THE PEOPLE VS ACOSTA, ANTONIETA SILVIA | TRF | CLOSED |
| ACOSTA ANTONIO DELGADO | D | 1392695 | 3/5/2008 | TRF | I | THE PEOPLE VS ACOSTA, ANTONIO DELGADO | TRF | CLOSED |
| ACOSTA CANDACE CORINNE KOBORSSY | D | 1504433 | 5/16/2008 | TRF | I | THE PEOPLE VS ACOSTA, CANDACE CORINNE K | TRF | OPEN |
| ACOSTA CAROLYN ENCINAS | D | 1270684 | 1/9/2008 | TRF | I | THE PEOPLE VS ACOSTA, CAROLYN ENCINAS | TUR | CLOSED |
| ACOSTA CESAR | D | 1396101 | 4/2/2008 | TRF | I | THE PEOPLE VS ACOSTA, CESAR | TRF | OPEN |
| ACOSTA CHARLEE MARINA | D | 608759 | 4/3/2008 | JVTRF | I | THE PEOPLE VS ACOSTA, CHARLEE MARINA | TRF | CLOSED |
| ACOSTA EDNA | D | 623094 | 1/28/2008 | CV | UD | GRP LOAN VS ACOSTA, R | MUNI | OPEN |
| ACOSTA ELIZABETH DIANA | P | 626756 | 5/13/2008 | CV | MCOMP | ACOSTA, L VS. SATURN CORPATION | SUPER | OPEN |
| ACOSTA FABIAN FONG | D | 1509458 | 6/11/2008 | TRF | I | THE PEOPLE VS ACOSTA, FABIAN FONG | TRF | OPEN |
| ACOSTA GARY SIMON | D | 1242488 | 3/17/2008 | CR | MISDEM | PEO VS ACOSTA JR., GARY SIMON | MUNI | PS |
| ACOSTA GLORIA V | PET | 427376 | 1/17/2008 | FAM | DISS | ACOSTA, G VS. RAMIREZ, C | SUPER | OPEN |
| ACOSTA JESUS GILARDO | D | 1393832 | 3/14/2008 | TRF | I | THE PEOPLE VS ACOSTA, JESUS GILARDO | TRF | OPEN |
| ACOSTA JOANNE LYNN | RSP | 427965 | 3/4/2008 | FAM | DISS | ACOSTA, J VS. ACOSTA, J | SUPER | OPEN |
| ACOSTA JORGE A | D | 1383514 | 1/2/2008 | TRF | I | THE PEOPLE VS ACOSTA, JORGE A | TRF | CLOSED |
| ACOSTA JOSE ANTONIO | RSP | 428329 | 3/28/2008 | FAM | DV | MORALES, L VS. ACOSTA, J | SUPER | OPEN |
| ACOSTA JOSE FAUSTO | D | 1501466 | 5/1/2008 | TRF | I | THE PEOPLE VS ACOSTA, JOSE FAUSTO | TRF | CLOSED |
| ACOSTA JOSE SERVANDO | PET | 427965 | 3/4/2008 | FAM | DISS | ACOSTA, J VS. ACOSTA, J | SUPER | OPEN |
| ACOSTA JUAN DIAZ | D | 1246316 | 6/16/2008 | CR | MISDEM | PEO VS ACOSTA, JUAN DIAZ | MUNI | OPEN |
| ACOSTA JUAN PABLO | D | 1241203 | 2/20/2008 | CR | MISDEM | PEO VS ACOSTA, JUAN PABLO | MUNI | PS |
| ACOSTA KATHLEEN L | D | 1502052 | 5/6/2008 | TRF | I | THE PEOPLE VS ACOSTA, KATHLEEN L | TRF | CLOSED |
| ACOSTA KATRINA MARIE | D | 1240922 | 2/22/2008 | CR | MISDEM | PEO VS ACOSTA, KATRINA MARIE | MUNI | OPEN |
| ACOSTA KHRYSTEN MARUQUEL | D | 1396304 | 4/1/2008 | TRF | I | THE PEOPLE VS ACOSTA, KHRYSTEN MARUQUEL | TRF | CLOSED |
| ACOSTA LENNIE BRUCE | P | 626756 | 5/13/2008 | CV | MCOMP | ACOSTA, L VS. SATURN CORPATION | SUPER | OPEN |
| ACOSTA MARIA F | D | 1244083 | 4/21/2008 | CR | MISDEM | PEO VS ACOSTA, MARIA FAUSTINA | MUNI | PS |
| ACOSTA MARY L | RSP | 429208 | 5/30/2008 | FAM | DISS | ACOSTA, A VS ACOSTA, M | SUPER | OPEN |
| ACOSTA MIGUEL | D | 1274194 | 3/5/2008 | TRF | I | THE PEOPLE VS ACOSTA, MIGUEL | TUR | CLOSED |
| ACOSTA RAMIRO | D | 1271892 | 3/11/2008 | TRF | I | THE PEOPLE VS ACOSTA, RAMIRO | TUR | CLOSED |
| ACOSTA RAMON | D | 1512140 | 6/23/2008 | TRF | I | THE PEOPLE VS ACOSTA, RAMON | TRF | OPEN |
| ACOSTA RAYMOND | D | 1386325 | 1/17/2008 | TRF | I | THE PEOPLE VS ACOSTA, RAYMOND | TRF | OPEN |
| ACOSTA RICKY | D | 626778 | 5/13/2008 | CV | MCOMP | GOLDEN STATE VS. ACOSTA, R | MUNI | OPEN |
| ACOSTA ROBERT ANTHONY | D | 1511397 | 6/19/2008 | TRF | I | THE PEOPLE VS ACOSTA JR, ROBERT ANTHONY | TRF | CLOSED |
| ACOSTA ROBERT R | D | 623094 | 1/28/2008 | CV | UD | GRP LOAN VS ACOSTA, R | MUNI | OPEN |
| ACOSTA ROMULO GUZMAN | D | 1279990 | 6/16/2008 | TRF | I | THE PEOPLE VS ACOSTA, ROMULO GUZMAN | TUR | OPEN |
| ACOSTA ROSA | D | 1242341 | 3/7/2008 | CR | MISDEM | PEO VS ACOSTA, ROSA | MUNI | CLOSED |
| ACOSTA RUDY BART | D | 1389569 | 2/11/2008 | TRF | I | THE PEOPLE VS ACOSTA, RUDY BART | TRF | OPEN |
| ACOSTA SARA CRUZ | D | 1242886 | 3/14/2008 | CR | MISDEM | PEO VS ACOSTA, SARA CRUZ | MUNI | CLOSED |
| ACOSTA SIMON | D | 1397171 | 4/8/2008 | TRF | I | THE PEOPLE VS ACOSTA, SIMON | TRF | CLOSED |
| ACOSTA STEVEN C | D | 626951 | 5/16/2008 | CV | MCOMP | PALIDSADES VS. ACOSTA, S | MUNI | OPEN |
| ACOSTA SUSIE | PET | 429012 | 5/16/2008 | FAM | DV | ACOSTA, S VS CARTER, M |